Government must rein in Big Tech and AI, Dáil hears
Mike Finnerty 18 Nov 2026
The government will not oppose a bill by the opposition which seeks to make it a crime to create intimate images of someone using generative AI.
Earlier this year, a wave of progressive political parties and organisations left Twitter in the wake of the Grok scandal, when it emerged that Twitter’s generative AI service was allowing users to produce intimate images of users without their permission.
The bill looks to amend the existing Coco’s Law, which was passed by the previous Dáil in 2020 after being introduced by Labour.
Introduced by Labour TD Alan Kelly, the bill puts the government’s relationship with Big Tech under the microscope.
An investigation by the Northside People concluded that the government were reluctant to hold organisations such as Facebook and Twitter to account and allow hate speech to flourish on social media platforms.
As the likes of Facebook, Twitter and TikTok have their European headquarters in Dublin, the report found that the government did not want to chase away the corporate tax revenue that came with it.
Despite that, the government has said it would not oppose this piece of Labour legislation.
Coco’s Law, as it currently stands, makes it a crime to distribute intimate photos of people with their consent and permission; the added wrinkle of generative AI emerging since the law was passed in 2020 has meant there is now a loophole within the Irish legal system.
Kelly explained, “the manner in which Grok was being used to undress people and the way that was being utilised were totally unacceptable.”
“Through this legislation we are updating the act to ensure that not just physical images, which were part of Coco’s Law, but also AI-generated images, are covered by the legislation. Six years ago, we did not see that far ahead. The bill also deals with companies that facilitate the sharing, distribution and manufacturing of such images,” he said.
He added it was “very much appreciated” that the government were not going to oppose the bill.
Local Labour TD Marie Sherlock said, “there was so much shock, horror and disgust at the start of this year when we saw what Grok was capable of online and the appalling commodification and exploitation of women and young girls in particular.”
The Dublin Central TD noted that in January, there was a public consensus that the tech giants were going to be held accountable for their actions, but that did not come to pass.
She said that in this instance, the government has been “behind the curve” with regard to the power of AI.
“When we look back to January this year, the Grok experience revealed and exposed just how powerless nation states are, or have allowed themselves to be, particularly here in Ireland,” she said.
“To a certain extent, the AI horse has bolted and we are gasping to catch up, but it is not too late,” she told the Dáil.
She welcomed that the government were willing to work with the opposition on this issue, but there needed to be a “very clear message” on how tech giants were going to be regulated.
Sherlock noted that major technological platforms are headquartered and have their Europe, Middle East and Africa headquarters located in Ireland and are part of massive projects developing artificial intelligence.
The Dublin Central TD borrowed the words of Italian Marxist philosopher Antonio Gramsci: “the old is dying, and the new has not yet been born.”
“That is the attitude we need to apply to our legislation. Our legislation cannot foresee the types of products that are going to be developed, but it can at the very least set down basic thresholds for decency, safety and child protection in the online space,” she said.
The Labour TD noted that AI has “very positive potential”, but it could also have a “catastrophic impact.”
“The reality is that because so many of the EU’s digital imports come from the US, we are beholden to a very small number of very big actors. Power is concentrated in the hands of a very small number of people, and there has not been political willingness to stand up and say what protections we need for our citizens or our people,” she said.
In January, Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon was among the first TDs to publicly announce they were quitting Twitter in the wake of the Grok scandal.
Since the Grok scandal, local TDs such as Green leader Roderic O’Gorman have quit using Twitter, as have the Green Party themselves, the Social Democrats and Labour, while progressive politicians have ceased posting on the platform altogether.
Gannon took aim at people who still use Twitter.
The Soc Dem justice spokesperson said, “we are heading very quickly into a very dystopian world in which these creeps on Twitter or other platforms can quite literally take a picture of a woman or young girl and turn it into a sexual abuse image.”
The Dublin Central TD said “these companies need to feel the full force of the law. They headquarter themselves here for a very specific reason – they benefit from our taxes – but that does not give them any justification or restrain us from going after any creep who enables a tool of this nature to be used against women or young girls in this country.”
“That should not even be something that we have to sit on. We should have been arresting people who provided those tools and arresting those who manipulated the images. There is no space for argument here.”
“The Departments that are still using that platform need to reflect upon what that says about us,” he said.
Gannon criticised Minister for Justice Jim O’Callaghan for still using Twitter, despite its clear shift towards amplifying far-right voices.
“That company should never be used by anybody within any of our Departments, but a justice Minister using it to admonish the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre is a step too far,” he said.
Gannon said it was important that the government jumped on the speeding train now instead of being left behind.
“We need to act quicker because this technology is evolving far faster than the legislative process within this House.”
Fine Gael junior minister Colm Brophy said that the government were committed to tackling online abuse of women.
“At a domestic level, the government is in the process of ensuring the full transposition of the violence against women directive, including the criminalisation of producing and distributing deepfake imagery.”
“Every person deserves to live free from violence. Every person deserves to live free from fear. Every person deserves to live free from abuse. That ambition, I believe, must continue to guide every single person, in government and opposition, Deputies and Senators, right across the Oireachtas,” he said.
The Dublin South-West TD added, “we must continue to challenge the attitudes, the myths and the misogyny that underpin the violence, while also ensuring that our response remains evidence-based and, I hope, united.”








