Opposition TDs hit out at “Thatcherite” Harris after controversial dole speech

Mike Finnerty 18 Nov 2026
Fine Gael leader Simon Harris

Local opposition TDs have formed an attack chorus on Simon Harris’ Ard Fheis speech, where the Fine Gael leader criticised the number of people on long-term unemployment benefits.

The speech by Harris, seen as a move away from the “progressive centre” image which Fine Gael had built up during the Varadkar era, has been poorly received by pundits and politicians alike.

Harris stated that being on the dole long-term was “not a way of life,” a comment which has been criticised by disability advocates.

Just over 17,000 people are in receipt of dole benefits for five years or more, a figure which costs less than the amount of money the government handed the greyhound industry in October’s budget.

Social protection spokespeople for Sinn Féin and the Social Democrats hit out at Harris’ comments.

Sinn Féin TD Louise O’Reilly branded Harris’ comments as “Thatcherite.”

“This is Thatcherite politics – blame people with the least power for the circumstances they face, and use them as a target while the government evades responsibility for its own failures,” the Dublin Fingal West TD stated.

“All the talk of Fine Gael’s internal navel-gazing and uncertainty about its identity was bogus. Simon Harris has shown exactly who Fine Gael are – a right-wing, Thatcherite party that protects the interests of the wealthy and privileged while punching down on the most vulnerable in society,” she said.

O’Reilly stated, “long-term unemployment does not emerge in a vacuum. Deprivation, a lack of opportunity, leaving education at a young age without the qualifications or support to move forward, and too few routes into decent work can all shape a person’s prospects,” she said.

O’Reilly said, “after 15 years in government, Fine Gael cannot wash its hands of these problems or pretend they are simply a matter of individual choice. It has failed to tackle the underlying causes, and now Simon Harris is blaming the people left to live with the consequences.”

Social Democrats TD Eoin Hayes remarked that Harris’ comments were an instance of Fine Gael “letting the mask slip.”

“What we heard from Simon Harris was nothing but a lazy regurgitation of his predecessor Leo Varadkar’s discredited ‘Welfare Cheats Cheat Us All’ 2017 campaign,” he noted.

“It is blatantly obvious from his speech that Harris is desperately trying to deflect from his party’s appalling near 16-year record in government by placing the blame for the country’s many problems on a tiny minority of people.”

Hayes noted, “we are talking about a very small group of individuals, with the long-term unemployment rate standing at just 1.3% of the workforce.”

There are fewer than 17,500 people on the dole for five years or longer, a figure that drops to 14,000 if people over the age of 60 are included.

Hayes stated, “it is extraordinary, but telling, that – at a time of full employment in Ireland – scapegoating the long-term unemployed should be the centrepiece of the Fine Gael leader’s address to the party faithful.”

“It conveniently sidesteps the real challenges facing the country, from the cost-of-living and energy crises to the housing and homelessness disaster,” the Dublin Bay South TD said.

“For a party that has recently been distracted by internal squabbling, all-time-low poll results and a damning report about its lack of identity, it doesn’t take much for the mask to slip when it comes to Fine Gael’s political priorities,” he further remarked.

Hayes commented that Harris’ comments were part of a calculated attempt by Fine Gael to move away from the social liberalism that defined the Varadkar years, partly so Harris can stake out a new political identity.

Other political analysts who have reviewed the Ard Fheis speech have noted that Fine Gael are sweating it because of increased competition from the likes of Aontú and Independent Ireland.

“Harris has been successful in reasserting his party’s increasing shift to the centre right,” Hayes commented, and added, “but in doing so, he has exposed Fine Gael as an uncaring party that has run out of ideas on social renewal and has little interest in standing up for our most vulnerable citizens.”

Related News