Government failing on public transport, Dáil hears
Mike Finnerty 18 Nov 2026
Local opposition TDs have put pressure on the government to reverse planned hikes to public transport costs in the new year.
People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy remarked “everyone who is stuck in their cars for hours watching their life slip away day by day should thank Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael because they are the ones who knowingly make choices that make it worse.”
This week, the Dáil discussed a motion by the Social Democrats which called on the government to reverse planned hikes to public transport costs; since the news broke in September, the news has been a millstone around the government’s neck.
The government’s defensive response on the issue was best exemplified by Cork TD Jerry Buttimer who claimed that the government “do not have money up the wazoo to spend on everything.”
The junior transport minister asserted “we have made choices,” which presumably includes the choice to increase funding for greyhound racing to €20.4 million for 2027 despite clear evidence of falling attendances and animal cruelty at race tracks across Ireland.
Labour TD Ciáran Ahern noted that the Minister for Environment himself, Darragh O’Brien, was not present in the Dáil to discuss the topic as he was at the COP31 in Turkey.
“I am sure the Minister is going to talk to delegates there about Ireland’s climate ambition, about delivery, about how seriously our government takes the climate crisis and about the actions required to mitigate its impacts. Blah, blah, blah.”
“The Minister can wax lyrical all he wants on the international stage about Ireland’s commitment to positive climate action. The reality at home is not only that he and this government are failing, but that they are actively undermining the efforts to reach our climate target; the fare increase is just one example,” the Dublin South-West TD sniped.
Fellow Dublin South-West TD Murphy said there was no economic sense in increasing costs for consumers, when passenger numbers are so high.
The NTA has told the Committee of Public Accounts that the operating cost per passenger is lower in 2025 than the 2019 equivalent figure.
For city buses, the cost per passenger fell from €2.08 in 2019 money to €1.91 in 2025.
For commuter rail, it fell from €4.15 per journey to €3.80.
For intercity services, it fell from €17.09 to €14.48, a full 15% drop.
Despite this (or in spite of this) the September decision by the government to hike prices during a cost of living crisis has gone down like a lead balloon among the opposition.
Murphy said that the government were increasing fares because it wants passengers to pay a bigger share of the overall cost of public transport.
The People Before Profit TD told the Dáil, “the NTA tells us the reason for the drop in operating costs per passenger is growth in passenger numbers but the government is increasing fares in the knowledge that this will cause passenger numbers to fall.”
“Why is this? Maybe it is because the services are so hopelessly overcrowded and the government has no plans to address that, so it wants to drive people out of public transport to reduce demand,” he speculated.
Dublin Mid-West TDs Mark Ward and Paul Gogarty got their lumps in at the government.
Ward said, “not only is the government expecting people to pay more, but it is actually asking them to pay more for less.”
“It expects families, workers, students, pensioners and other commuters to pay more for less; services are not being delivered and ghost buses are becoming the norm.”
The Sinn Féin TD warned, “major public transport projects are years behind schedule.
Harkening back to his time as a councillor on South Dublin County Council, Ward said he and fellow councillors voted on the Clonburris development.
The plan calls for the development of over 10,000 homes and that services like transport, schools and other public amenities were to be built concurrently with the houses; this has not happened, per Ward.
Recalling the process, Ward said, “not everybody agreed on the plan at the council and people had different ways of doing things, but we all agreed that we had to have adequate public transport in the plan.”
“In fairness to South Dublin County Council, it played its part and produced a plan but successive government ministers have not been doing their jobs,” and said that public transport was the one area that the government has been falling down on.
Ward told the Dáil “I am frequently contacted by residents who bought homes in a strategic development zone; this was approved and fast-tracked on the promise of sustainable, high-frequency, high-capacity public transport.”
“Instead, homeowners, residents and commuters have been left with an under-resourced rail service that is already failing to cope with the current demand.”
“Peak-hour services are constantly beyond capacity. Passengers at Clondalkin and Fonthill train stations are regularly left to stand in cramped and unsafe conditions, and sometimes they struggle to board the trains at all. Carriages are frequently excessively hot and stuffy, creating an unpleasant passenger experience.”
Gogarty joked that the Minister for Transport was pushing fare prices up to keep demand down.
The independent TD said, “however, it is no joke for the people who are suffering as a result of this collective incompetence.”
“It makes no sense whatsoever to hike public transport costs in a time of climate crisis, when costs are rising everywhere, and when some people have no alternative to public transport.”
He questioned why car parking was not being allowed in areas such as Saggart Seven Mills, Adamstown and Kilcarbery when the public transport services in those areas were not up to standard.
“The Minister is confusing car ownership with car usage. Of course, the people in social housing get even fewer spaces.”
Gogarty took aim at Simon Harris’ comments on welfare recipients (see page four for more), and remarked, “going by Simon Harris’ comments, none of these people work, none of them have kids that need access to schools and childcare, and none of them have relatives that visit.”
Gogarty stated, “I said it 10 or 15 years ago, that these problems were going to happen. Now they are going to happen in another ten or 15 years because of bad planning.”
Buttimer conceded, “sometimes, we (in government) do not have that joined-up thinking approach that we need to have.”
“I do not for one second think that everything is perfect; it is not.”
He said that the government were committed to improving public transport not just in Dublin, but right across Ireland, and funding in October’s Budget was proof of that.








