Blame game in Swords as créche delays council housing plan

Mike Finnerty 18 Nov 2026

A row over housing has broken out between government party councillors and opposition party councillors on Fingal County Council.

At a meeting of Fingal County Council on November 9, the meeting discussed a planned 360-home development in Swords.

Councillors from Labour, Sinn Féin, the Social Democrats, Aontú, and various independents said that the project should not go ahead in its current form, as it meant that a crèche would be privately owned.

The existing plan called for 249 affordable homes, 111 social homes and a new crèche; the opposition insisted that the council itself should own the crèche.

Ever since mid-2025, when Labour walked from a coalition with Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael on Fingal County Council, the government parties have had to deal with independents on a vote-by-vote basis, but the combined opposition numbers on the council are enough to overrule the government parties in tight votes such as this.

The planned construction, which was due to start in January 2027, has now been delayed.

Fine Gael councillor Tom O’Leary criticised the opposition for the state of affairs, stating that “mantras do not build homes.”

The Balbriggan warned, “we now risk losing a year and facing higher costs.”

The Fine Gael councillor said that the delays could result in a 6% increase on a €350,000 home, which would mean an additional €21,000 is required for would-be homeowners.

“Swords needs homes alongside childcare, schools, transport, pitches and parks. I want this agreement brought back urgently,” he stated.

“Mantras do not build homes — builders build homes. Let’s get these 360 homes and the crèche built.”

Taoiseach Micheál Martin waded into the debate; during a heated Dáil exchange with Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne on housing, the Taoiseach referenced the vote.

The Taoiseach criticised what he called “hypocrisy” by the opposition.

“About 249 affordable and 111 social houses are ready to go, with the tender agreed and everything with the local authority; a Labour Party-led motion, supported by the Deputy’s party, was a refusal to give that land over for those houses.”

“That is the hypocrisy they go on with all the time. How can the Deputy get up here and talk about housing delivery but just casually say that, because of who owns a crèche, people will not get access to those affordable or social houses for some time yet?”

“The Deputies are so intent on ideology as opposed to substantial and pragmatic progress,” the Taoiseach claimed.

Opposition party councillors state the situation is not as black and white as the government parties make out.

Sinn Féin councillor John Smyth warned against giving public land to private developers at a discount, stating “we have had a number of cases across the country where house prices have risen, and they are no longer affordable,” as a result of private development.

The Swords councillor said, “it was a sign of desperation that government parties attacked opposition councillors for raising serious questions.”

“Sinn Féin are not trying to block homes at Baile na Móna; we are insisting that Fingal County Council gets this deal right and meets the housing needs of the public.”

He stated, “we will not give any private developer a free hand; we will ensure that all the necessary protections, obligations and conditions are in place.”

Social Democrats councillor Joan Hopkins said, “on principle, we would like to keep public land in public ownership.”

“Developers need to make a profit; they make in and around 60,000 per unit; I am not sure if disposing of the land is good value for money.”

The Howth-Malahide councillor said that in situations like this, a public construction company was needed as opposed to the current model.

She said that in this scenario, it would be helpful to have a cost analysis for private versus public costs.

Swords councillor Dean Mulligan said, “we have seen countless examples across this county where local councillors have been held to ransom” on specific conditions attached to home development.

He said the créche must be part of the development, because in some instances it is a condition on families making the move into the home or not.

The independent councillor said, “I would love the infrastructure to be delivered in tandem, but we have seen time and time again where this hasn’t happened.”

Labour councillor Brian McDonagh explained, “we have a responsibility to make sure we are getting value; the market structure and how this whole thing works is that we acquire the land at a really high price, and we are now disposing of it at a much lower price.”

The Howth-Malahide councillor said there was no mention in the document of how much money the council were getting for the créche, or the land associated with it.

“The concern is very clear; while people may be paying capped prices for the houses, the price levels of the créche will be reflected in private profits, and those future profits will be subsidising this deal.”

He said he “did not see a structural reason” for the council to give up the land.

Independent councillor Jimmy Guerin acknowledged, “I know people have concerns about the price of land, but it is about entering an agreement with people to provide social and affordable housing for an acceptable price.”

The Howth-Malahide councillor said, “what we need in Fingal and in the country are houses; I don’t really mind who builds them, so long as they are provided.”

He said the deal “makes perfect sense” and that it was about optics as far as Fingal County Council were concerned.

“It is very important for the people who are waiting for houses that they see we are taking action to deliver houses,” Guerin stated.

Fianna Fáil councillor Darragh Butler said that the opposition “had good intentions” on the issue and “we all want more houses and créche places,” but said that progress was needed.

“I have no doubt if we mess this around we will end up in a worse and more costly situation,” the Swords councillor warned.

Fine Gael councillor Aoibhinn Tormey dubbed the Labour motion “very, very dangerous.”

“When we talk about a housing crisis, the only solution is to build more homes; last month, councillors voted to reduce housing units in Dunsink by 1,200 and now we have hundreds of social homes, all under 400 grand, at risk by a frivolous motion by this.”

The Howth-Malahide councillor said, “we need to be building homes instead of being sidelined by issues like this.”

Ultimately, Fingal County Council voted by 20 votes to 18 to include the créche in the development; the plan will now be sent back to council management.

As mentioned, the opposition parties on Fingal County Council (as well as various independents) had the necessary numbers to overrule the government parties on this issue.

Labour’s seven councillors, Sinn Féin’s four councillors, Aontú’s three councillors, and the Social Democrats’ two councillors made up the majority of the bloc, with various independents of different ideological backgrounds voting alongside the opposition.

Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael’s seven councillors could only attract support from four independent councillors.

Related News