Site icon Dublin People

Suspended sentence for man involved in pub brawl that resulted in permanent brain damage

By Isabel Hayes

Two men who took part in a violent fight which left a man with permanent brain damage have been sentenced for their role in the brawl.

Darren Robinson (45) who threw the first punch in a fight between two groups of men who had been watching a match in a pub in December 2023 was given a two year suspended sentence.

His co-accused Mark Madden, who threw a number of punches during the fight, was jailed for 18 months by Judge Martin Nolan.

Both men pleaded guilty to a count of violent disorder outside Pilsner Pub on Ushers Quay, Dublin 8 on December 3, 2023. Neither man was responsible for the assault that left the victim with permanent brain damage.

The perpetrator of this offence was previously jailed for four years while a fourth accomplice, who pleaded guilty to violent disorder, was jailed for 18 months.

Detective Garda Richard Pender told the court that the victims in the case – a group of Slovakian men living and working in Dublin – had been Christmas shopping in town before they went to the pub to watch a soccer match.

The offenders came into the pub and, for reasons that remain unclear, words were exchanged before Robinson tried to grab a knife from the pub kitchen. He was stopped by staff before the Slovakian group moved outside and were followed by the offending group.

A fight broke out, with CCTV footage played in court showing Robinson throwing the first punch. Madden threw a number of punches. During the melee, one of the Slovakian men was seen hitting the ground unconscious. As his friends gathered around to help him, the offenders left the scene.

Gardaí were called and, recognising one of the offenders from the footage, called to Oliver Bond Flats where Madden was apprehended. Robinson came forward to gardaí of his own volition.

Madden, formerly of Oliver Bond Flats but currently living in Birmingham in the UK, has 31 previous convictions including drugs, assault causing harm and road traffic offences.

Robinson, with an address at Block E, Mellowes Quay, Dublin 8, has 42 previous convictions including for drugs and road traffic matters.

A victim impact statement was handed into court but not read aloud.

Pieter Le Vert BL, defending Madden, said his client’s previous convictions are about 18 years old and that he has turned his life around after moving to the UK. He is currently studying Sports and Fitness Science at the University of Birmingham and has two children.

He was visiting home at the time of the assault, got a phone call from a friend seeking assistance in a fight and “stupidly” responded.

Sentencing Madden, Judge Nolan noted no-one knows the reason for the dispute that left a man seriously injured who was knocked or hit to the ground and hit the back of his head. He took into account Madden’s guilty plea and work history but noted Madden “knew what was happening and participated fully”.

He jailed him for 18 months.

Defence counsel for Robinson said he was a plasterer who struggled with substance abuse when he lost his business during the recession. He has moved out of Dublin with his kids and has not come to garda attention since this offence.

Sentencing Robinson, Judge Nolan said he accepted, having viewed the footage, that he played a full role and he seems to have been drunk at the time. He noted that he has a strong work record and is responsible for the care of his five children in “a difficult domestic situation”.

He said there is “a certain category of cases” where the courts can take into account a person’s family responsibilities adding that this was one such case.

Judge Nolan sentenced Robinson to two years in prison which he suspended in full on strict conditions.

Exit mobile version