By Sonya McLean
Two Dublin men have been sentenced for their role in attacking a man after one of them claimed that the victim was “a dirty rapist”.
Nathan Walsh (30) of Ballyshannon Road, Kilmore Road, Beaumont, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to theft and assault causing harm to the man, while Lee Cunningham (29) of Park Lawn, Mount Prospect Avenue, Clontarf, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm.
A third man, Brian Delahunty (35) of Hollytree Terrace, Ballymun, Dublin 11, was jailed for 18 months last year after he also pleaded guilty to assaulting the man, causing him harm.
Passing sentence, Judge Orla Crowe said this was a case of “three against one” adding that from the CCTV footage it was apparent that this was a brutal assault.
The judge said the victim was “blamelessly finishing his night when he had the misfortune of meeting these three”. She said the attack had an impact on him and she would have to ‘mark the seriousness of the assault’.”
She noted that Walsh kicked the man many times, including to his head before he went through his pockets, while Cunningham connected with the victim with his knee. She accepted that Cunningham was the less aggressive of the three attackers.
Judge Crowe noted that Walsh was very aggressive, was found in possession of the victim’s mobile phone and that he made a “nasty allegation” about the victim.
It was accepted that Walsh, a father of three, has since made efforts to deal with his addiction. Judge Crowe sentenced him to three years in prison with the final 12 months suspended on condition that he engage with the Probation Service for a year upon his release.
Judge Crowe sentenced Cunningham to 18 months in prison with the final six months suspended on strict conditions including that he engage with the Probation Service for 12 months.
The court heard that the victim, who is now 41 years old, was attacked on Temple Lane South in Dublin City Centre at 3am on May 23, 2023. Gardaí arrived at the scene to find the man lying on the footpath with blood coming from his mouth and swelling around his eye.
Garda Conor Conway told David Perry BL, prosecuting, that Walsh was arrested within an hour of the assault after officers had viewed CCTV footage of the attack. He was wearing the same clothes as he had been earlier and still had the victim’s mobile phone and bank cards on him.
Walsh told gardaí in a subsequent interview that the victim was a “dirty rapist”.
“He is a dirty rapist. I will do it again because he is a dirty rapist,” Walsh told gardaí.
CCTV footage of the assault was played to the court. It was accepted that Walsh threw the first punch and kicked the victim multiple times to the head after he fell to the ground. Walsh can then be seen going through the man’s pockets.
It was also suggested to the court that Cunningham can be seen on that footage trying to bring the assault to an end as the victim lay unconscious on the ground.
Gda Conway accepted that Cunningham came in at the end of the assault and that his “knee connected with the head of the victim”.
The garda said that men did not know the victim before the assault. He was approached by the three men while he was walking down the street and he told the group he didn’t want to fight. His iphone and wallet were stolen from him.
The court heard that the men were initially charged with robbery but pleaded guilty to the offences before the court on a trial date.
Gda Conway said Cunningham was also identified by gardaí after viewing footage and he was arrested on May 27, 2023.
He said to gardaí that the victim tried to rob his phone and he pushed him away before the man was assaulted by another person. He claimed that he stood back and watched the assault and then the victim ran head first into a wall.
He later admitted that he kicked him once or twice but then added that he barely touched him.
A medical report and victim impact statement was handed into court. The victim was later treated for headache and neck pain.
He said in his victim impact statement that he is scared to go out at night and can no longer work. He doesn’t have money to pay rent and bills and his body feels like it is “getting weaker and weaker”.
Gda Conway said Walsh had 55 previous convictions for offences including robbery, criminal damage and assault. He was on a four-year suspended sentence for an attempted robbery when he committed this offence.
Cunningham has 18 previous convictions for assault causing harm, violent behaviour in a garda station, theft and public order offences.
Gda Conway agreed with Justin McQuade BL defending Walsh that it was “an ugly incident” but that his client puts himself at the scene.
He accepted that he was a young man who was completely out of control at the time of the offence and was “regularly intoxicated”.
Gda Conway acknowledged that Walsh has not come to garda attention for some time and seems to be dealing with his addiction.
He agreed with Oisin Clarke BL defending Cunningham, that although he initially “diluted his own involvement” in the offence, he accepted he was there, once he was shown CCTV footage of the attack.
Counsel said that his client instructs that he didn’t know Walsh or the victim before that night.
Walsh’s father told the court that his son began dabbling in drugs as a young child and was taking crack cocaine by the time he was 15. He said he has since seen “a massive change” in Walsh as he is getting treatment for his addiction.
Mr McQuade submitted that his client has made “significant documented progress” and that there are “green shoots” that indicate he is beginning to change his life.
Mr Clarke said his client first came to garda attention when he was 21 years old. He has an issue with alcohol and was intoxicated on the night in question.
Counsel said his client had a difficult childhood and he “sought refuge in alcohol” but he has started to attend for treatment.
“He has stopped drinking in a problematic way,” Mr Clarke said.
Counsel submitted that Cunningham’s role was clearly less than the others involved.
“He has unresolved trauma that comes out as anger when he drinks,” Mr Clarke said which he said is the main factor in Cunningham’s offending.
He also asked the court to consider that Cunningham can be seen on CCTV footage trying to get the other two men to stop the attack.

