Cinema is in a healthy state when a film by an esteemed writer/director can be sold on his name alone.
Martin McDonagh follows up his Oscar-nominated hit The Banshees Of Inisherin with Wild Horse Nine, another movie where two idiots bicker with each other for two hours.
John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell star as bumbling CIA agents who are awaiting the overthrow of Chilean president Salvador Allende and are sent to Easter Island on an assignment.
Malkovich’s character, CIA veteran Chris, then tells his colleague, the bumbling Lee, that he is terminally ill and wants to make the most of his time on Easter Island by writing his memoirs.
The setup is very similar to In Bruges; an older veteran has an uneasy but fundamentally strong relationship with a younger, bumbling colleague.
With the film set in the weeks before the overthrow of Allende in September 1973, the film embraces the shaginess that comes with great two-handers such as Mikey and Nicky or Withnail and I.
We would usually criticise filmmakers for recycling themselves so blatantly, but when the film is this good, who cares?
McDonagh does arguments better than anyone, and having top-tier talent like Malkovich and Rockwell go at each other like an old married couple is worth the price of admission.
Malkovich has only two Oscar nominations to his name; his most recent nomination came in 1994 for the Clint Eastwood thriller In The Line Of Fire, a personal favourite of this critic.
In that year, Malkovich was unlucky to come up against Tommy Lee Jones for The Fugitive; this year, there is every chance that Malkovich finally walks away with an Oscar.
It would be a fitting win; Malkovich has rarely been better than he is here; he plays the vulnerability with real gravitas but is still the odd character actor we know and love.
Over the years, Malkovich has given countless great performances in both bigger and smaller movies, and there is something so engaging and unconventional about him that you can’t stop watching.
Here, Malkovich finally gets the role where he can use every trick in his toolbox; the slightly off-tempo cadence and delivery, the nasal voice, and a prodigious ability to make even the silliest of monologues profound.
One early scene has Malkovich’s character explain that if democracy is brought to a country, the country becomes gay, and that means they produce better cheese.
It is that kind of circular logic and hyper-specificity that McDonagh shines at; McDonagh writes absurd, acidic dialogue the same way that Billy Wilder did.
Having great actors like Malkovich and Rockwell deliver it is the cherry on top.
It is strange that Malkovich and McDonagh have never worked together before, but we wouldn’t be opposed to another few collaborations between the two.
Wild Horse Nine is a two-hander in the most traditional sense; it has two stars sharing the majority of scenes together, and everyone else is secondary.
Sam Rockwell is very much Malkovich’s equal, and seeing Rockwell slip back into McDonagh rhythms is a treat.
Rockwell’s shtick of playing the frustrated idiot is as funny as it has ever been.
While we won’t spoil the exact context for the scene, there is one scene where Rockwell just sits there, dumbstruck, while Malkovich monologues; McDonagh has the discipline to keep the camera focused on Rockwell while Malkovich babbles on, and it is one of the highlights of the movie.
Of course, the similarities to In Bruges will make you want to go back home and throw that movie on, and it generates a fun thought experiment; would this film be better if it was just Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson again?
In any case, Malkovich and Rockwell are a killer combination, the Dwight Yorke and Andy Cole of dark comedy.
The plot eventually reveals itself, but it takes a back seat to the dialogue.
The characters being CIA operatives who destabilise democracies on weekends is almost an incidental detail.
This becomes clear when the great Parker Posey shows up for exactly two scenes as Rockwell’s wife on the telephone in the most thankless of roles.
By having the movie be a two-hander, it means that interesting actors get sidelined; it is a shame to have an actress of Posey’s calibre and relegate her to just two scenes.
Tom Waits continues his trend of only working with auteurs; he has popped up in Paul Thomas Anderson movies, movies by the Coens and Jim Jarmusch; if Tom Waits shows up for a scene in your movie, it means you are now officially an auteur.
Waits appeared in McDonagh’s 2012 film Seven Psychopaths, and deploying Waits is an ace up any director’s sleeve.
Steve Buscemi fares slightly better as Malkovich and Rockwell’s CIA boss.
Like Malkovich, it is surprising that Buscemi and McDonagh have never worked together, as Buscemi is a perfect fit to deliver McDonagh dialogue.
Buscemi’s specific brand of being a smarmy know-it-all was deployed to great effect in The Death Of Stalin, and this role has him operating in a similar mode.
If you haven’t already surmised, Wild Horse Nine is as political as a mainstream studio film can get.
Early on, Malkovich tells a British couple that he was “on the Irish side all along”, and the film discusses just how destabilising the CIA has been in the modern world.
In the case of Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, it felt that McDonagh, an Englishman with Irish parents, was a bit out of his depth talking about race and police brutality in the American South.
Here, a director like McDonagh is perfectly poised to reckon with the effects of American foreign policy.
In the McDonagh catalogue, Wild Horse Nine doesn’t quite reach the highs of In Bruges or Banshees Of Inisherin, but it doesn’t need to be in competition with his other films.
Any time a film is sold on the director and writer’s name on the poster, that is a net positive for films as a whole.
We are not going to start slapping down a film just because a writer likes to return to the same well.
If the well results in dialogue this witty and biting, it makes sense that McDonagh will want to repeat the same winning formula.
A famous rock history tidbit is Mike Love once telling Brian Wilson to “not f*** with the formula”, and the same is true here.
Wild Horse Nine doesn’t quite have the same punch as In Bruges because we know what to expect from a McDonagh movie by this stage, but it is no less watchable because of it.

